Key findings
- Across 32 ReviewTactic customer businesses with 5 or more Yelp reviews (not a random sample), the average rating was 4.56 on Google and 3.64 on Yelp (November 2026).
- Of these 32 customer businesses, 28 rated lower on Yelp than on Google, 4 rated higher and none were equal (November 2026).
- The median business rated about 0.7 stars lower on Yelp. Median ratings were 4.62 on Google and 3.90 on Yelp (32 businesses, November 2026).
- Median review counts were 405 on Google and 24 on Yelp. Compared business by business, the median was about 12 Google reviews for every Yelp review (November 2026).
- Businesses with 100 or more Yelp reviews had the smallest gap, 0.4 stars on average, and all 5 still rated lower on Yelp (only 5 businesses, November 2026).
In our data, the same business usually scores lower on Yelp than on Google. Across 32 of our customer businesses (November 2026), the average was 4.56 stars on Google and 3.64 on Yelp, about 0.9 stars lower. Of the 32, 28 rated lower on Yelp, 4 rated higher and none were equal.
One caution up front. These businesses came to us because of bad reviews, so the sample is not random and likely skews low on Yelp. Read it as a pattern among businesses with review trouble, not a rule for all businesses.
Own a business with a low Yelp rating? See what you can do or get a free Yelp check.
Google reviews vs Yelp: the numbers
On average, the 32 businesses scored 4.56 on Google and 3.64 on Yelp. That is about 0.9 stars lower, almost a full star. The median business rated about 0.7 stars lower, with median ratings of 4.62 on Google and 3.90 on Yelp.
Embed this chart
| Google rating | Businesses | Google average | Yelp average | Lower on Yelp |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4.5 and above | 22 | 4.7 | 3.8 | 20 of 22 |
| 4.0 to 4.49 | 9 | 4.3 | 3.5 | 7 of 9 |
A strong Google rating did not carry over. Businesses rated 4.5 or higher on Google averaged 3.8 on Yelp, and 20 of 22 rated lower there. Those rated 4.0 to 4.49 on Google averaged 3.5 on Yelp.
Why Yelp ratings run lower than Google
Yelp ratings likely run lower for a mix of reasons. Businesses ask happy customers for Google reviews, while Yelp tells them not to ask. Unhappy customers post on both sites unasked. And Yelp leaves the reviews it does not recommend out of the rating. Our data does not test each reason on its own.
- Happy customers go to Google. Praise piles up where owners ask for it.
- Unhappy customers go everywhere. An angry customer often posts unasked, on both sites. On Google that complaint sits among hundreds of reviews. On Yelp it sits among a couple of dozen.
- The not recommended filter. Yelp says not recommended reviews do not count in the star rating or the review count. It also says it aims to showcase users who actively contribute. So a happy customer who rarely posts may not move your Yelp rating at all.
- Yelp tells businesses not to ask. Yelp's help page says asking for reviews "may hurt your Yelp rating", because its software may not recommend reviews that seem prompted. Google lets a business ask customers for reviews, as long as it offers nothing in return and does not ask only the happy ones.
| Topic | Yelp | |
|---|---|---|
| Asking customers for reviews | Allowed, with no reward and not only to happy customers | Yelp says asking may hurt your Yelp rating |
| Filtered reviews shown on a separate list | No | Yes, the not recommended list |
| Median reviews in our sample (32 businesses) | 405 | 24 |
Here is how to get more Google reviews without breaking Google's rules.
Which businesses see the biggest gap
The gap was widest for businesses with 20 to 99 Yelp reviews and for service and other businesses. Those with 20 to 99 Yelp reviews were 1.1 stars lower on average, and 13 of 15 rated lower. Every group, by size or by type, still averaged lower on Yelp than on Google.
One example shows how this happens. It is a single case.
A home-buying company had three one-star Yelp reviews. All three came from first contact: an unsolicited marketing email, texts about an offer, and one estimate sent by text. None came from a finished deal.
Businesses that quote and prospect meet many people who never buy. Those people can still post, and a business with a short Yelp list has few other reviews to soften them.
Service and other businesses (22) were roughly one star lower on Yelp on average, and 18 of 22 rated lower. Food and drink places (7) were about 0.6 lower, and all 7 rated lower. The remaining 3 had no category. Both groups are small, so read the split as a hint.
| Yelp reviews | Businesses | Average gap (stars) | Lower on Yelp |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5 to 19 | 12 | 0.9 | 10 of 12 |
| 20 to 99 | 15 | 1.1 | 13 of 15 |
| 100 or more | 5 | 0.4 | 5 of 5 |
The gap did not shrink steadily as Yelp reviews grew. It was 0.9 stars at 5 to 19 Yelp reviews, 1.1 at 20 to 99 and 0.4 at 100 or more. All 5 businesses in the top group still rated lower on Yelp. Five is a small group, so read the drop as a hint.
Yelp's not recommended reviews, explained
Not recommended reviews are reviews Yelp's automated software leaves out because it judges them less helpful or reliable. Yelp says it aims to showcase users who actively contribute, and reviews that seem prompted by the business may not be recommended. They do not count in the star rating or the review count.
Yelp says about three quarters of all its reviews are recommended. For 2025, Yelp says about 70% of roughly 22 million new reviews were recommended and 17% were not.
Not recommended reviews stay readable on a separate list, linked below the recommended reviews on the business's Yelp page. An unfair one-star review on that list is not hurting your rating, and a real five-star review there is not helping it.
Check that list before you report anything.
What you can do about a low Yelp rating
- Reply in public. A calm, specific reply under the review shows the next reader how you handle problems.
- Report reviews that break Yelp's rules. Report from your Yelp for Business account, under the one reason the review's own words support. Yelp decides. It will not take a report that a review is simply false, so pick the rule the review breaks.
- Check first contact first. For reviews from people who never bought, look at the reason "It doesn't describe a personal consumer experience". Yelp removed over 193,700 reported reviews in 2025, and 25% of them did not reflect a firsthand consumer experience. In 2024 it removed over 185,100, and 26% were not firsthand.
- Do not ask for Yelp reviews. Yelp says asking can hurt your Yelp rating. Put your review requests into Google instead.
Not sure which of your Yelp reviews qualify? Get a free Yelp check.
The steps, the nine report reasons and two real decided reports are in our guide on how to remove a Yelp review. For replies, see how to respond to bad reviews.
Method and limits
The sample is 32 of our customer businesses with 5 or more Yelp reviews and a confirmed match to their Yelp listing. We looked up 56 locations to find them.
The Google rating is the average of the Google reviews we hold for each profile.
The Yelp rating and Yelp review count come from a third-party review data provider's listing data, collected November 2026.
Business names are withheld. We publish aggregates only, never a row per business.
The bias, plainly: these businesses came to us because of bad reviews, so the sample is not random.
The groups are small. Each band and business type holds between 5 and 22 businesses. The one business rated under 4.0 on Google is counted in the totals but not shown as a band. Headline averages and medians are shown to two decimals; other ratings and gaps are rounded to one.
Free Yelp and Google review checks
The Yelp check is done by hand by a person. The Google check is automatic. If you later want a Yelp report filed, it goes out from your own Yelp for Business account, as a user you added, at your request.
Free Yelp check: send us your Yelp page and we'll tell you which reviews break Yelp's rules. Yelp decides.
Also on Google? Run the free Google removal scan
Sources (checked November 2026)
- Yelp Support: Does Yelp recommend every review?
- Yelp Support: Don't Ask for Reviews
- Yelp 2025 Trust & Safety Report, press release (2026-02-25)
- Yelp 2024 Trust & Safety Report, press release (2025-02-05)
- Google Maps: Fake engagement and rating manipulation policy
- The Yelp report dialog, as seen in our own filings from a customer's Yelp for Business account, November 2026
- Our own sample of 32 customer businesses, November 2026 (method above)
Cite this study
Palicz, A. (2026). Yelp vs Google reviews: the same business scores almost a full star lower on Yelp. ReviewTactic. Aggregate analysis of 32 customer businesses, November 2026. https://reviewtactic.com/resources/yelp-vs-google-reviews/